Skip to content

Poetic Memories series

This eight-volume series of wire-bound books reproduces a remarkable set of scrapbooks compiled around 1948 by Irene Scott—the woman who preserved and shared Isabel Eddy’s writings, which included events in their lives, excerpts from her son’s diaries, and Jeanette MacDonald’s conversations and letters. Irene passed these materials to Dorothy Dillard, who decades later contacted Sharon Rich, enabling her to incorporate this rare source material into Sweethearts.

Each scrapbook page pairs a vintage magazine photo with an often substantial quote from Isabel’s letters or memoirs. Because portions of Irene’s correspondence with Dorothy have been lost, these scrapbook excerpts contain unique insights not found elsewhere.

Sharon Rich has written brief introductions for Volumes 2 through 8, highlighting the revelations each book brings to light. Volume 1 stands apart with an extended, photo-rich biographical chapter on Irene Scott, including her friendship with Jeanette’s sister, Blossom Rock (from around 1920 onward), and verified documentation reproduced from Irene’s daughter—both of whom were interviewed for the book.

For anyone interested in the origins and authenticity of the Isabel Eddy letters, Volume 1 is an essential starting point.

Today in J/N History

1948 “Three Daring Daughters” is released. (Jeanette and Nelson originally were to do this film together; MGM insisted on Jose Iturbi instead.) Jeanette sings “Sweethearts” (from the 1938 film with Nelson). With the intro lyrics she looks at Iturbi, who is accompanying her (and with whom her character is in love). But when she gets to the main part (a duet with Nelson in their film) she turns and sings instead to the orchestra! This curious fact is covered up by shooting her face in closeup so you don’t notice how very odd this is that she does not face Iturbi.

Upcoming Events

Sweethearts Documentation

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

This field is required.

Archives